How To Choose the Right Email Marketing Tool – GetResponse vs. Mailchimp vs. AWeber

Email MarketingNo matter what niche you’re targeting, email marketing will always be one of your key lead generation and user engagement channels.

Some of the most successful niche marketers like Pat Flynn, Spencer Haws and, our very own, Stuart Walker, have been able to generate regular income from niche blogs thanks to their email lists.

Without an engaged email list, your niche marketing business is never completely under your control. Your website traffic is just a Google Search or Facebook algorithm update away from coming crashing down to the ground.

With an email list, however, things are under your control.

But the first step of starting an email list is choosing the right email marketing tool.

Personally, I’ve been a MailChimp user for the last 1 year. Before that, I used AWeber regularly. But just a few months back I gave GetResponse a try and really liked what I saw.

All these three are top email marketing tools with lots of great features and functionalities. However, you need to choose one, and preferably stick to it for the long run, since it can be a real pain to shift your lists and all the settings from one email service to another.

So to help you choose the right email marketing tool for your niche blog, I’m going to compare some of the key features of these three tools and make it easier for you to make the right choice.

 

(P.S. If you'd like to download a free list of 34 ways to grow your email list click here or the image below)

 

 

Choosing the Right Email Marketing Tool – There’s No Absolute Answer

Before I go deeper into comparing these three awesome tools, I need to clarify that there’s no one tool that I, or anyone else, can call the best. It all depends on your business needs.

MailChimp, AWeber and GetResponse are three of the top email marketing tools and have almost all the bases covered. But by comparing them feature to feature, you can see which one fits your business needs better.

For example, some of you might prefer the tool that has better email templates, while others would choose the one that offers better analytics. It’s all about your preferences.

So without further ado, let’s compare some of the key features of GetResponse, MailChimp and AWeber, and see how they can add value to your niche marketing business.

 

Getting Started with a Free Account

 Getting started with GetResponse is quite easy. You can sign up for a free 30 day trial using your email address, without giving your credit card or payment information, and use most of the features including the auto responder. However, you can’t add more than 250 contacts on the free account.

 

getresponse1

 

Similarly, starting a Mailchimp account is also quite simple. You can sign up for a free account without entering your credit card or payment information.

There’s no time limit to your account either. But you won’t be able to send emails using a free Mailchimp account once your total subscribers exceed 2000.

The free version also does not offer the auto responder feature.

 

mailchimp1

 

AWeber also offers a 30 day free trial account which will give you access to all the features except for the auto responder.

You’d also need to provide your credit card information while signing up for your free trial. After the first month, you’ll be charged $19/month and will be allowed up to 500 contacts on your list.

 

aweber1

 

The Verdict - Getting Started with a Free Account

I’ll go with GetResponse in this section since it gives you access to almost all the features in its free account without asking for any credit card or payment information.

It gives you enough time and flexibility to try and test all the features and see if it fits your requirements.

 

Winner: GetResponse

 

 

Neil Patel“GetResponse is head and shoulders above the rest. I call it my email marketing secret weapon!”  - Neil Patel (Kissmetrics, Crazy Egg & Quicksprout)

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

Setting up Your Campaign for Email Opt-ins

 

GetResponse

Once you sign up for a GetResponse account, you need to start collecting emails with opt-in forms. For this you need to configure your first campaign, which is easy.

Just below the main navigation, there’s a menu on the right side from where you can click on “create a campaign”.

 

getresponse4

 

Click on this link and name your new campaign.

 

getresponse5

 

Once you name your campaign, edit your campaign settings to customize your sign up message and other details.

 

getresponse6

 

getresponse7

 

When you’re done with setting up your confirmation message, you can start adding contacts and setting up your opt-in forms.

 

Mailchimp

Setting up opt-in forms in Mailchimp is slightly different from GetResponse. You can create only one opt-in form for each contact list you have.

To set up your opt-in form and confirmation email, you need to sign in to your account and select the “List” option in your dashboard.

 

mailchimp5

 

Here, you can create a new contact list and add contacts, or select an existing one.

 

mailchimp6

 

For example, for this particular list, you can create an opt-in form by selecting “Signup forms” from the drop-down menu.

 

mailchimpforms

mailchimp8

 

You can create a standard HTML form by selecting the “General forms” option, or you could create embedded form or popups below.

But to configure your opt-in emails, you’d need to go to the general form settings first.

Here, you can configure your automated emails for every stage of the subscriber’s lifecycle.

 

mailchimp9

 

mailchimp10

 

The emails you create here will work for all the other types of opt-in forms you create for this particular contact list.

 

AWeber

AWeber probably has the simplest process for setting up an opt-in form and confirmation message.

You’re simply required to follow a three step process in which you add your campaign details, personalize your message and customize your content.

 

aweber-setup-1

 

Add personalization and brand symbols here

 

aweber-setup-2

 

Finally, customize your confirmation email content and add the URL to your confirmation page.

 

aweber-setup-3

 

Once you’re done with this step, you can embed an opt-in form to your blog or website and start collecting emails.

 

(P.S. If you'd like to download a free list of 34 ways to grow your email list click here or the image below)

 

The Verdict – Setting up Your Campaign for Email Opt-ins

Out of these three, I found the set up process of AWeber as the most convenient and user friendly, especially for newbies.

 

Winner: AWeber

 

 

chris ducker"Email has been absolutely instrumental in the growth of my businesses over the last five years. A big thank you to AWeber for supporting me in my business over the past five years by being my email marketing provider." - Chris Ducker (Author, Blogger and Podcaster)

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

Email Templates

 

GetResponse

GetResponse offers more than 500 hundred ready to use and mobile responsive email templates. You can find templates for different industries and niches according to their categories.

 

getresponsethemes

 

Mailchimp

Mailchimp also offers more than 300 attractive and mobile responsive email templates that are categorized according to different industries.

It also gives you the option of creating your own template from the scratch.

 

mailchimptemplates

 

AWeber

AWeber offers the richest collection of email templates, more than 600, which are both attractive and responsive in design.

 

AWeber-email-templates

 

The Verdict – Email Templates

Although all three of these services promote their email templates as a high value feature, I personally don’t consider html email templates, with heavy visuals and designs, necessary for niche marketers. I think they’re more suitable for established brands.

For niche marketers, simple text emails usually work the best. So I’d stick to that approach.

 

Winner: Draw

 

 

adamconnell"The more relevant that your opt-in forms and opt-in bribes are, the better your conversions will be" - Adam Conell (BloggingWizard)

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

 

Message Builder

GetResponse

The GetResponse design team has done a great job, especially with the message builder. You can create an email message or newsletter by selecting the “Create a Newsletter” option from your main account dashboard.

 

getresponsedashboard

 

Here, you have the option of either going for the standard drag and drop message builder or opt for an html source editor.

I recommend going for the standard email creator since it’s easy and gives you more options.

 

getresponsemessagebuilder2

 

Before building your email message, you’d need to add some basic info about it.

 

getresponsemessagebuilder3

 

When you press the “Next” button, you’ll have the option of choosing from a wide range of email templates.

But as I mentioned in the last section, I prefer using plain text emails since they perform better in my experience.

To go for a simple text email, click on “Start from Scratch” and select an email layout to start creating your email.

 

getresponsemessagebuilder4

 

This snapshot shows the standard message builder of GetResponse.

You can simply drag and drop image and text blocks to the body of your email message, edit text formatting and access several other standard editing options.

You can also add social sharing buttons and custom button links to your email body.

On the right side of the window, you can see the mobile preview of your email. You can also test your message before sending it, from the “Test Message” button on the top right hand corner.

In the “Test Message” drop down, do keep an eye on the Spam Score, and try to keep it as low as possible to avoid your email from being spammed by major email services.

 

Mailchimp

Mailchimp is renowned for its attractive UI and easy to use options. So naturally, using its message builder is also a breeze.

To build your email message, click on the “Create Campaign” button on your main dashboard.

 

mailchimp2

 

Here, you can choose the type of email you want to send. If you plan to split test your emails as well, then go for the A/B split campaign. Otherwise you can opt for the regular campaign type.

 

mailchimp3

 

Once you select your message type, you’ll be required to choose a contact list or a segment from it. You’ll also need to provide some basic information about your email campaign, like campaign name, subject and tracking settings.

 

mailchimp4

 

Again, I don’t recommend using any design templates. Instead, go for a plain one column email layout. Once you’re in the message builder, the drag and drop functionality makes things really easy for you.

 

getresponsemessagebuilder5

 

You can add text and image boxes, code snippets, social media sharing buttons and linked buttons to the email message body.

You can also get a desktop and mobile preview of your email before sending it to your audience.

 

AWeber

Let’s have a quick look at the AWeber message builder now. To access it, click on the “Create a Broadcast” button on your account overview page or the “Messages” tab in the top navigation bar.

 

aweber-message-builder-1

 

When you click on this button, you’ll have the option to select the type of email you want to create. Like the other two email services, I’d go for a drag and drop email message builder.

If you want to slip test your email, you can click on the split test link below the broadcast button (more on this later in the post).

 

aweber-message-builder-4

 

The message builder has all the standard drag and drop functionalities. Every time you drop an element into your message body, you’d see additional options for configuring it.

 

The Verdict – Message Builder

 

There’s not much difference between the actual functionality of the three message builders (I like all of them).

But for me, the ease of setting up the message, strong tracking options and a clutter free message builder makes Mailchimp a close winner on this one.

 

Winner: Mailchimp

 

 

sujan"It’s 2015 and it’s clear that email marketing still works" -Sujan Patel

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

Configuring the Auto responder

GetResponse

As a niche marketer, you’ll need to keep your email subscribers engaged all the time. For this, you’ll need to create high quality content and send it regularly to your subscribers using automated email sequences .

GetResponse offers some powerful auto responder features. You can create an auto responder from the main navigation menu.

 

getresponseautoresponder1

 

Here you can create your auto responders on a number of criteria.

 

getresponseautoresponder2

 

I’m going for the time-based auto responder since that is the most frequently used type by internet marketers. But you can explore the other types as well which are quite useful in certain conditions.

You can configure the time-based auto responder in the following window.

 

getresponseautoresponder3

 

You can also enable the “time travel” option to send your emails at a certain time to different time zones.

For example, if you send an email to your list at 9AM according to your time zone, subscribers in other time zones will also get it immediately, which will hurt your email open rates.

The time travel option will adjust your email delivery times according to the different time zones of your subscribers and make sure that all of them get your email at 9AM in their time zones.

 

getresponse-auto-responder-2

 

Once you’re done with the settings, you’ll need to create your email in the standard email message builder. You can also view all your automated emails in a grid format and make any necessary changes.

 

getresponse-auto-responder-3

 

Overall, setting up the GetResponse auto responder is pretty straight forward and gives you several advanced features to play with.

 

Mailchimp

Mailchimp refers to the autoresponder feature as automation. You can access it from navigation menu on your main dashboard.

 

mailchimpautoresponder1

 

To create an autoresponder series, you’ll need to create an automation workflow, and link it with the relevant contact list that’ll receive the automated emails.

You can also create automation workflows for specific segments of a contact list.

 

automation_button_createworkflow

 

automation_list_chooselistdropdown

 

You can select from a list of predefined automation workflows or create your own customized workflow. For demonstration, I’m choosing the welcome email workflow.

 

automation_list_welcomemessage_clickselect

 

You can start your automation workflow after adding some basic information.

 

automation_ab_setup

 

This information will be applied by default to every new email you add to this particular workflow. But you can change the settings and customize each email separately as well.

After this step, you’ll need to create emails for your automation workflow, verify automation settings, test your email and activate the automation workflow.

 

AWeber

AWeber refers to its auto responder feature as “follow up series”. You can access it under the messages menu in the main navigation.

It’ll take you straight to the message builder where you can create your email, and configure your automation settings.

 

aweber-auto-responder

 

You can also enable the feature to send emails according to the time zones of your subscribers.

However, when you add a new email to a follow up series, AWeber automatically sends it to your contacts. So you’ll need to keep that in mind while adding new emails to an existing auto responder series.

The Verdict – Auto responders

I personally found the Mailchimp and GetResponse automation features more comprehensive and easy to configure. But if I had to choose one service, it would be GetResponse.

 

Winner: GetResponse

 

 

 

UONN1J3n“GetResponse is superior to any other email marketing software. Its UI is awesome and super fast. In terms of features, it’s ahead of everyone; it’s also super easy to set things up.” - Peep Laja (ConversionXL

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

 

 

Split Testing

GetResponse

For me personally, and for most internet marketers, email split testing is an important feature. You need to make sure that you’re sending optimized emails to your subscribers with the highest probability of being opened and read.

Thankfully, there’s nothing complex about split testing, or A/B testing as it commonly known, in GetResponse. You get the option to turn on split testing when you’re creating a new email message.

 

splittestinggetresponse1

 

Once you create your email, you’ll be able to test its effectiveness on a number of criteria. You can test your subject lines, from field, sending time and email content.

 

splittestinggetresponse2

 

Whichever test you’re running, you’d need to come up with 2-3 variations and run the test to find the best one.

You can also turn on the “Send best message automatically” option to send the best performing message to your complete list.

 

splittestinggetresponse3

 

There’s nothing really complex about A/B testing in GetResponse and it really makes it a breeze for even amateur users.

 

Mailchimp

To run A/B test in Mailchimp, you’ll need to create an A/B split campaign, from the “Create Campaign” tab in your main dashboard.

 

mailchimp123

 

You can test delivery times, names and subject lines, and choose a winner by open rates, click rates or a manual condition.

 

AB test mailchimp1

 

After you configure the test conditions, you’ll be required to choose a contact list, or a segment of it, for the test campaign. The rest of the process is the same as creating a normal email campaign.

 

AWeber

In AWeber, you can find the split testing link below the “Create a Broadcast” button under the Messages tab.

 

aweber-message-builder-1

 

aweber-email-split-test1

 

In the split testing section, you can configure the test conditions and the number of emails you want to test.

When you save these options, AWeber will create email drafts that can be edited and scheduled for sending from the drafts section.

 

The Verdict – Split Testing

For me, GetResponse wins hands down in this one because it makes split testing very simple for even the most amateur users, yet provides you all the advanced options as well.

 

Winner: GetResponse

 

 

 

 image_400x400"The truth is, most online businesses could spend a lot more time testing their email marketing campaigns, and this means you can stand out from the crowd by being one of the companies that does." - Chris Hexton (GetVero)

Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

 

Email Deliverability Rates

There are dozens of reviews on the internet, both positive and negative, about the deliverability rates of all three of these services. In my opinion they’re almost the same when it comes to email deliverability.

The variation comes from the kind of subscribers you have and the niche you’re in.

For example, I use Mailchimp for two completely different niches, and there’s a significant difference not only in the deliverability and bounce rates, but also in the email open rates on the same service.

These are three top email marketing companies so you can safely rely on them to deliver emails to your subscribers.

 

Winner: Draw

 

(P.S. If you'd like to download a free list of 34 ways to grow your email list click here or the image below)

 

User Experience

Both Mailchimp and GetResponse are more pleasing to the eye and have a much more modern outlook that makes it easier to find different options and play with their features.

AWeber, on the other hand, makes things easier for users because of its setup wizard and an overall simplified approach.

But I’d still prefer a modern outlook over a dull interface.

 

Winner: Draw between Mailchimp and GetResponse

 

 

"The concept of Email Blogging, a strategy which I personally think is one of the easiest and most profitable ways to make money online. - Glen Allsop (ViperChill)"

 Click here to Tweet this!

 

 

Customer Support

Support is so important especially when you get stuck with a feature and need urgent assistance.

At the same time, customer support is more about experiences so your experience with a particular service might be completely different to mine.

But for me, AWeber just has a better-rounded support system that is available for urgent issues as well.

And that for me is the key since I can’t wait for 24 hours (or 48 hours on weekends) for my emails to be responded.

 

Winner: AWeber

 

Third Party Integration

When you choose an email marketing tool, you'd ideally want it to support different CMS, social media tools, ecommerce platforms, payment gateways and other web based applications.

Thankfully, AWeber, Mailchimp and GetResponse, all three of them integrate with almost all the leading third party applications like Shopify and Shopify Plus, Google Analytics, WordPress, Joomla, Freshbooks, PayPal and countless others.

So no matter which one of these three email marketing tools you choose, you don't need to worry about third-party integrations.

Winner: Draw

 

 

integration

 

 

Pricing Plans

Now that I’ve gone through most of the key features of GetResponse, Malichimp and AWeber, let’s have a look at the pricing structure as well.

Here are the different packages that GetResponse offers

 

pricing getresponse

 

The most popular package, 2500 subscribers for $25 per month, gives you access to all the features including a 30 day free trial of GetResponse landing pages ($15/month after that).

The pricing structure for Mailchimp is slightly different. You can either go for a monthly plan or choose the “pay as you go” plan in which you can purchase credits for specific campaigns.

 

mailchimppricing

 

Here’s the chart for “Pay as you go”.

 

mailchimppricing1

 

AWeber pricing starts from a base price of $19 per month for 500 subscribers. You do get a slight discount if you bill quarterly or yearly.

And they offer a $1 trial here.

 

pricing aweber1

 

For more than 500 subscribers, you’ll need to pay additional fee. Here’s how this works.

 

pricing aweber

 

The Verdict – Pricing Plans

Mailchimp is a bit expensive considering the features they’re offering. AWeber and GetResponse offer comparatively better pricing plans. But I think GetResponse gives you more value for your money.

 

Winner: GetResponse

 

A Quick Look at the Features

Here’s a summary of the key features of all the three services to simplify the decision for you.

 

emailservicecharts

 

Here’s a summary of my winners for all the features that I’ve discussed in this post.

 

  • Getting Started with a Free Account – GetResponse (Winner)
  • Setting Up Your Campaign for Email Opt-ins – Aweber (Winner)
  • Email Templates - Draw
  • Message Builder – Mailchimp (Winner)
  • Configuring the Auto responder – GetResponse (Winner)
  • Split Testing – GetResponse (Winner)
  • Email Deliverability Rates - Draw
  • User Experience – Mailchimp and GetResponse (Draw)
  • Customer Support – Aweber (Winner)
  • Pricing Plans – GetResponse (Winner)

OVERALL WINNER: GET RESPONSE

 

>> Get started with the winning autoresponder, GetResponse, here.

 

 

 

 

A Final Word on the Three Services

As I said at the start, GetResponse, Mailchimp and AWeber are three of the best email services right now. So there’s always going to be very little between them when you’re making a choice.

But you do have to select one, of course.

When I first started out, I used Mailchimp a lot and I think it’s a great service. Their UI is pleasing to the eye, the user experience is great and the features are all there.

But I have encountered a few cases where they banned users in the internet marketing niche for promoting their freebies. So that’s a bit of  a scare for me.

AWeber has been a long time market leader and many of the top guys still use it. It certainly has all the features you need for effective email marketing.

But for me their message builder and auto responder was a bit of a turn off. Still it’s a mighty good service.

GetResponse has most things right about it. It has a modern interface, advanced email marketing and automation features.

Its split testing features are better than the other two services, and the landing page and survey features are real game changers. It is, however, slightly more complex for newbies and might take a little more time to get used to.

In short, you can’t pick one service as the best. It depends on your preferences and business needs.

My personal choice is GetResponse, but it could easily be AWeber or Mailchimp as well if my business needs change.

 

 

Jawad Khan
Jawad Khan is a content marketing consultant and a freelance blogger for hire. Follow him on his blog, WritingMyDestiny, Twitter and Google+

Comments (21)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. I chose to go with Mailchimp because you can start building a list for free. I am only getting 1 subscriber every now and then and if I had to pay for a service with my small amount of traffic, it would be harder to get going.

    I've tried Aweber before and I think it is def the best. When I'm getting constant traffic and sign up to my list, I may move back to Aweber.

    • NicheHacks says:

      You need to read some of our posts on building your list on the "email" category Mark. Lots of good ideas there to grow your list

  2. Great camparism. How I wish I saw this article before paying for my mad Mimi account. Thank you for this article. I'm going to see how its goes with Mad Mimi to see if quick switch is possible . Thanks

  3. Sergio Felix says:

    Hey Stuart, I normally use AWeber but I also have dormant accounts with MailChimp and another one with GetResponse which I've got through JVZoo's in order to have the benefit of automatically adding people whenever I promoted for somebody else but I never used that (long story).

    But anyway, my question is regarding the lenght of your blog posts, how much time (on average) do you spent putting a blog post like this one?

    I don't think I have ever visited any of your blog posts before and said something like "I'm pretty sure this was written in one hour and blasted to the public" so how the heck do you do it? LOL

    Thanks in advance man, you're like a walking gold mine for internet marketers.

    Sergio Felix

    • Jawad Khan says:

      Hey Sergio,

      Stuart has an awesome team that makes this happen

      http://nichehacks.com/about-me/meet-team/

      In terms of hours, I think I spent around 10 hours researching, writing plus taking snapshots for this post.

      Glad you liked it 🙂

      Cheers,
      Jawad Khan

      • Sergio Felix says:

        Oh doh! That explains everything lol thanks a lot Jawad and 10 hours? Wow...

        I knew there was a lot of efforts and thoughts put into this so congrats for doing such an outstanding job man!

        • NicheHacks says:

          As my man Jawad said I have a team of writers which I'm making moves to make more well known as currently a lot of people don't seem to really know.

  4. Tiffany says:

    Often I find myself getting duplicate emails from senders who are using Mail Chimp.

    One thing about Get Response, you can only be added to a list once. If you are already subscribed, nothing happens (using API). Say for instance you changed your opt-in offer but kept the same campaign. Or someone downloaded it a while ago and wants to get it again. They can't. You'd have to create a new campaign.

    Additionally with Get Response, if someone accidentally deleted the newsletter confirmation message, and wanted it to be sent again, the only way to do that is for the list owner to log into their dashboard and manually resend it to them. If they try to sign up for it again through the form, they can't... Whereas Mail Chimp will just send multiple confirmation messages if they keep trying to sign up. This is a pain when using Get Response and testing your own opt ins.

    • NicheHacks says:

      I would think every Autoresponder only allows people to join each list once with the same email address. Someone can't be on the same list more than once. They can however be on multiple different lists you have for the same site.

  5. Jim says:

    The major problem is that I learn both MailChimp and Getresponse do not allow or limited niches such as supplements etc.

  6. Bruce says:

    Good timing on the article. I am in the throws of trying to decide which one to go with. I tried the free trial for MailChimp only to find out that it did not include the AutoResponder which is one of the main reasons that I need the service. Currently I am just getting my opt-in pages out on the web so do not want to pay until I start getting some responses. I have looked a a few WP plugins, but not too sure if this is the way to go.

    I am also currently looking at "SendinBlue". They are fairly new to the game but I have noticed a few IM's using this service. Does anyone have any feedback on them?

    Thanks for the article.

    Bruce

    • NicheHacks says:

      You'll need a plugin to collect emails but you also need an autoresponder to store and managing and mail those people. Never heard of SendInBlue. I'd stickwith something tried and tested like Aweber or GetResponse for now.

    • Jawad Khan says:

      Hey Bruce,

      I've done a bit of research on SendinBlue as well. It's a promising tool and might be a good option for someone just starting out, since it gives you the autoresponder feature with the free version.

      But it has a LOT of improvements to make before it can be compared with GetResponse or AWeber

  7. Ranga says:

    Just a simple query.

    Can't we use Google Forms for collecting email addresses and also configure the same as "autoresponder" by adding a simple javascript to it?

    Any thoughts on this, as it can save tons of money for startups?

    Thanks

  8. Bruce says:

    Thanks for the comments. I think I may give them a try as I am a sucker for start up companies. I know they do not have all the bells and whistles that the big boys have but maybe in time they will. I just really like their bio.

    I have spent my working career taking 2-3 person companies and helping them build their computer requirements until they became became to large for my interests and then hire staff for their future.

    Bruce

  9. Ngan Son says:

    The comparison so detail. I used Aweber since 2011, it work very well.

  10. GetResponse became the final choice for me too. I like all that they have to offer. Plus they have some awesome list building tutorials as well

    Cheers